In 1992, the Rev. David A. Bremer began services at U.P.C following pastorates in Southern California and Indiana, and continues through to now. Pastor Bremer, a native of Shelbyville, is a graduate of Earlham College and Princeton Theological Seminary. He also studied at the Universities of Oslo and Copenhagen and New College, Edinburgh University, Scotland.

A hallmark of Rev. Bremer's years has been encouragement of diversity within the church. More than 20 nations and four continents have been represented in 21st Century UPC membership and attendance, many of those people brought to Bloomington by the global appeal of Indiana University.